Language:EnglishEspañol →

What Happens If You Owe More on Your Mortgage Than Your Home Is Worth?

TL;DR

If your mortgage balance is higher than your home's current market value, you have negative equity. You may still have options, including staying in the home, refinancing if eligible, or pursuing a lender-approved short sale. Before selling, calculate your mortgage payoff, estimated selling costs, and potential remaining debt so you understand your financial options.

What Does It Mean to Owe More on Your Mortgage Than Your Home Is Worth?

When you owe more on your mortgage than your property could reasonably sell for, your home is considered underwater or upside down. This situation is also known as negative equity.

For example, imagine your Rhode Island home is worth approximately $300,000, but your outstanding mortgage balance is $340,000. You owe $40,000 more than the home's estimated market value, before accounting for selling expenses.

Negative equity can happen for several reasons. Home values may decline after you purchase, you may have borrowed against your equity, or you may have purchased the property with a small down payment and not yet paid down much of the principal.

It is important to understand that owing more than your home is worth does not automatically mean you are in financial trouble or behind on your mortgage. You can have negative equity and still make every monthly payment on time.

The situation becomes more challenging when you need to sell, relocate, or reduce your housing expenses because the proceeds from a traditional sale may not be enough to pay off your loan.

Start by determining your actual mortgage payoff and your home's current market value. Your remaining loan balance may differ from the official payoff amount because of accrued interest, fees, or other charges.

Can You Sell a House When You Owe More Than It Is Worth?

Yes, it may be possible, but the process can be more complicated than a traditional home sale.

When you sell a house with a mortgage, the loan generally must be paid off or otherwise resolved as part of the transaction. If the sale price is lower than the amount owed, you must determine how the difference will be handled.

For example, suppose you owe $340,000 on your mortgage and your home sells for $300,000. If selling expenses total another $18,000, the available proceeds would leave a $58,000 shortfall before accounting for any other adjustments.

In this situation, you generally cannot assume that selling the home will automatically eliminate the remaining debt. You may need to contribute additional funds, negotiate with your lender, or explore a different option.

One possibility is a short sale, in which the lender or mortgage servicer agrees to accept less than the full mortgage balance from the sale. The lender's approval is necessary, and the process may involve reviewing your financial circumstances, the proposed sale price, and other loan requirements.

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, borrowers should specifically ask whether the lender will waive the remaining deficiency. Get any agreement to forgive the unpaid balance in writing before completing the transaction. Otherwise, you could remain responsible for some or all of the difference, depending on the agreement and applicable law.

If you own a property in Providence, Warwick, Cranston, or another Rhode Island community, a real estate professional can help you evaluate the likely sale price. Your lender and closing attorney can help clarify what would be required to complete a sale with negative equity.

What Options Do You Have if Your Mortgage Is Underwater?

The right option depends on whether you can afford your monthly payments, whether you need to move, and whether you have savings or other resources available.

Option 1: Stay in the Home and Build Equity Over Time

If your mortgage payments are affordable and you do not need to move, staying in the home may be a reasonable choice.

As you pay down the principal, your loan balance can decrease. Home values may also rise over time, although appreciation is never guaranteed.

This option can give you time to improve your financial position without needing to cover a large shortfall immediately. However, consider your ongoing housing expenses, the home's maintenance needs, and whether staying fits your longer-term plans.

Option 2: Explore Refinancing

Refinancing replaces your existing mortgage with a new loan. However, negative equity can make refinancing more difficult because many lenders require sufficient equity and specific credit, income, and loan qualifications.

Some specialized programs may be available to eligible borrowers depending on the mortgage type and current program rules. Do not assume that refinancing is possible simply because you have made payments on time.

Contact your current mortgage servicer to ask whether any refinancing or other loan options are available for your circumstances.

Option 3: Ask About a Short Sale

If you need to sell but cannot cover the difference between the sale proceeds and your mortgage payoff, ask your lender whether a short sale may be considered.

The lender typically must review and approve the transaction. If there are additional mortgages or liens on the property, other parties may also need to approve the sale.

Before proceeding, clarify in writing whether the lender will forgive the remaining deficiency or retain the right to pursue it. You should also ask a qualified tax professional whether debt forgiveness could have tax consequences.

A short sale can take longer than a traditional sale because of the required approvals and documentation. Do not assume an offer can close until the relevant parties have approved the terms.

Option 4: Discuss Other Loss-Mitigation Options

If your financial circumstances have changed and you are struggling to make payments, contact your mortgage servicer to ask about loss-mitigation options.

Depending on your loan and circumstances, possibilities may include a loan modification, repayment plan, or other workout arrangement. Eligibility is not guaranteed, and the available options vary.

A housing counselor can help you review your budget, understand the process, and communicate with your lender.

What Should You Do if You Cannot Afford Your Mortgage Payments?

Being underwater and being unable to make mortgage payments are two different problems, but they can occur together.

If your income has decreased, your expenses have increased, or you have fallen behind, acting early is important. Waiting until you receive a foreclosure notice may reduce the time available to explore solutions.

Start with these steps:

  1. Contact your mortgage servicer. Explain your financial situation and ask which loss-mitigation options may be available.

  2. Gather your financial documents. Collect your latest mortgage statement, income records, bank statements, tax returns, and a list of monthly expenses.

  3. Review your budget. Determine whether you can maintain your current payments or need a different arrangement.

  4. Seek housing counseling. A qualified housing counselor can help you understand available options and prepare the information your lender may request.

  5. Get legal advice when needed. If foreclosure proceedings have started or you are considering a short sale, consult an attorney about your rights, deadlines, and potential remaining liability.

Rhode Island homeowners who are struggling with mortgage payments can contact the RI Housing Help Center. It offers free, confidential, HUD-approved housing counseling and helps homeowners review options for avoiding foreclosure. 

If you live in Massachusetts or Connecticut, look for a HUD-approved housing counseling agency serving your area or use the federal housing counseling resources available through HUD.

Be cautious of companies that promise to eliminate your mortgage debt, guarantee foreclosure prevention, or demand large upfront fees. Contact your lender or a reputable housing counselor before signing an agreement or transferring money.

How Can You Plan Your Next Move When You Have Negative Equity?

Before deciding whether to sell, stay, or pursue another option, calculate what each choice could mean for your finances.

Begin with three numbers:

  • Current market value: Estimate what your home could realistically sell for based on comparable properties and its condition.

  • Mortgage payoff: Request an official payoff statement from your lender or servicer.

  • Estimated selling expenses: Account for real estate commissions, closing costs, applicable taxes, and other transaction expenses.

Subtract the expected selling expenses and mortgage payoff from the estimated sale price. If the result is negative, you have a potential shortfall that needs to be addressed before a traditional sale can close.

You should also consider how much time you have, whether you need to relocate, and whether you can afford to remain in the property. If you have multiple loans secured by the home, include those obligations in your calculations.

A local real estate professional can help you evaluate the property's likely market value and discuss buyer demand. Your mortgage servicer can explain loan-related options, while an attorney or qualified tax professional can address legal liability and potential tax consequences.

The best next step depends on your financial position, not just the home's value. Understanding the numbers early can help you avoid making a rushed decision and identify which options are worth exploring.

If you are considering selling a home in Rhode Island, Massachusetts, or Connecticut and are concerned that your mortgage balance exceeds its value, Alex Parmenidez can help you understand the real estate side of the process and coordinate with the appropriate professionals as you evaluate your next move.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sell my house if I owe more than the mortgage balance is worth?

You may be able to sell, but the sale proceeds may not cover the full mortgage payoff and selling expenses. You may need to contribute funds or obtain lender approval for a short sale or another arrangement.

Does being underwater on my mortgage mean I will lose my home?

No. Negative equity alone does not mean you will lose your home. If you can afford your payments, you may be able to remain in the property and build equity over time. Foreclosure risk is a separate issue associated with default and the applicable legal process.

Will my lender forgive the remaining mortgage balance after a short sale?

Not automatically. Ask the lender whether the short sale agreement includes a full waiver of the deficiency and obtain written confirmation. Your remaining liability depends on the agreement and applicable law.

Can I refinance if my home is worth less than my mortgage?

It may be difficult, but eligibility depends on the loan, lender, and any applicable specialized programs. Contact your mortgage servicer to discuss the options available for your situation.

What should I do first if I owe more than my house is worth?

Request your current mortgage payoff, estimate the home's market value, and calculate the potential shortfall after selling expenses. Then discuss your goals with your lender and a qualified real estate professional before deciding whether to sell or remain in the home.

Thinking about buying?

Let's talk through your numbers first.

A 30-minute call covers what you can afford comfortably, what taxes and insurance really cost in the town you're looking at, and which loan programs fit you. You work directly with Alex from the first call to closing.

Schedule a buyer call

English or Spanish · Call or text 401-426-4857 · Contact form

Alexander Parmenidez · Broker Associate | REALTOR® · Coldwell Banker Realty · Licensed in RI, CT & MA
196 Waterman St, Providence, RI 02906 · C: (401) 426-4857 · O: (401) 351-2017 · [email protected] · alexparmenidez.realtor

Check out this article next

¿Qué Sucede Si Debe Más por su Hipoteca de lo que Vale su Casa?

¿Qué Sucede Si Debe Más por su Hipoteca de lo que Vale su Casa?

Si el saldo de su hipoteca es mayor que el valor actual de mercado de su casa, tiene un patrimonio neto negativo

Read Article